The Employment and Labour Relations Court ruled that National Bank of Kenya must pay former senior manager Kelvin Jumba KSh4 million after finding his termination unfair.

Justice Onesmus Makau said the bank’s refusal to provide the investigation report on which the dismissal was based rendered the disciplinary process unfair.

Jumba joined the bank in June 2014 as a relationship manager for county governments and was promoted to Senior Manager, Special Projects and Partnerships in July 2022, a role that involved seeking business opportunities.

In November 2022 the bank alleged that Jumba held invoices from Nouveta Limited worth KSh10.9 million for seven months, claiming he failed to verify and forward them for payment under a three-party arrangement with Nairobi City County.

The bank’s Head of Employee Relations Stephine Opiyo testified that standard procedure required the receiving department to confirm service delivery before approving payment, and that the unpaid invoices had triggered a dispute and financial loss.

Jumba contested the allegation, saying the delay was caused by unfinished contractual arrangements and the county’s failure to release funds, and that he had consulted the bank’s financial controller who advised that payment could not be processed until contracts were finalised.

The bank also issued a second show-cause letter accusing Jumba of engaging JamboPay, owned by Webtribe Limited, without the required internal approvals, alleging he acted without consulting his manager or following procurement procedures.

Jumba responded on November 16 denying the accusations and requesting the investigation report, which the bank refused to disclose, stating the document was confidential and intended for management only.

The bank suspended Jumba on November 2, 2022, served the first show-cause letter on November 9, and the second letter (date not specified) later in the month, before holding a disciplinary hearing on November 29 where Jumba attended without a colleague and complained that the panel acted as both accuser and decision-maker.

In December 2022 the bank terminated Jumba, stating in the termination letter that his negligence had caused the KSh10.9 million loss, and Jumba subsequently filed a claim seeking a declaration of unlawful dismissal, KSh6.9 million in compensation equivalent to twelve months’ salary, a certificate of service, costs and interest.

At the hearing Jumba admitted to holding the Nouveta invoices but maintained the delay was due to unresolved contracts and cited a June 3, 2021 letter from the bank’s managing director to Webtribe indicating the bank’s willingness to partner with JamboPay.

The bank’s witness acknowledged that the investigation report was a confidential management document and that no onboarding policy or guide covering the relevant period had been produced in court.

Justice Makau rejected the bank’s justification for withholding the report, questioning how an employee could defend himself against allegations based on evidence he could not access.

The court’s order for KSh4 million compensation highlights concerns about employers keeping disciplinary investigations confidential.