The High Court dismissed an application to freeze the factories and bank accounts of New Kenya Co-operative Creameries (New KCC) in response to a KSh419.7 million claim lodged by Lodwar-based distributor Naipa Supermarkets Limited.

The dispute originates from a milk distribution agreement signed on January 1, 2022 and amended in 2024, covering processed milk, milk powder, butter and ghee across Kapenguria, Lodwar, Lokichogio and nearby border settlements, and is now before an arbitral tribunal that has yet to rule on either party’s claim.

Naipa argued that New KCC breached the arrangement by appointing Darusalam General Stores and Contractors Limited as an additional distributor in Lodwar and sought a court order to prevent the sale, lease, transfer or charging of New KCC’s factories, vehicles, equipment and property, as well as to restrict withdrawals from its bank accounts, requesting KSh420 million in security within 14 days.

The application was made after President William Ruto announced at an 7-October 9, 2026 summit in Nairobi a KSh8 billion government programme to restructure and modernise New KCC, prompting Naipa to warn that restructuring or privatisation could enable asset transfers before arbitration concluded.

New KCC, through company secretary and chief manager for legal affairs Irene Mbito, said the 2022 agreement did not grant Naipa exclusive distribution rights, noted that Naipa had reduced purchases and stopped collecting products from its Eldoret depot, and claimed Naipa owed KSh4.9 million as of January 10, 2025, adding that freezing accounts would disrupt milk purchases, processing, distribution and payments to farmers, workers, suppliers and transporters.

Justice Patrick Otieno ruled that the orders sought were overly broad, stating “To grant the same would be to effectively immobilize and cripple the respondent,” and describing the restrictions as “disproportionate and rather draconian”, noting that Naipa had not shown New KCC was preparing to dispose of assets or was insolvent.

The judge also observed that Naipa had not identified any specific assets for attachment or provided their estimated values, that the KSh8 billion announcement did not prove funds were available to meet the claim, and that the Privatization Authority was not a party, warning that an order stopping restructuring would affect its statutory role, adding “That would run affront the right to be heard.”